6 M A T E R I A L S E V A L U A T I O N • J A N U A R Y 2 0 2 0 VOLUME 78 • NUMBER 1 JOURNAL STAFF PUBLISHER: Neal J. Couture, CAE DIRECTOR OF PUBLICATIONS: Toni Kervina EDITOR: Jill Ross ASSISTANT EDITOR: Cara Schaurer PRODUCTION MANAGER: Joy Grimm GRAPHIC DESIGNER/ILLUSTRATOR: Synthia Jester ADVERTISING SALES: Jessica Miller REVIEW BOARD TECHNICAL EDITOR John Z. Chen, Schlumberger ASSOCIATE TECHNICAL EDITORS John C. Aldrin, Computational Tools Sreenivas Alampalli, New York State Department of Transportation Ali Abdul-Aziz, Kent State University Narendra K. Batra, Naval Research Laboratory (retired) John Z. Chen, Schlumberger Yiming Deng, Michigan State University John C. Duke, Jr., Virginia Tech Trey Gordon, SpaceX Dietmar Henning, Level III Service LLC Cara A.C. Leckey, NASA Langley Research Center Mani Mina, Iowa State University William E. Mooz, Met-L-Chek Co. Ehsan Dehghan Niri, New Mexico State University Yi-Cheng (Peter) Pan, Emerson Inc. Anish Poudel, Transportation Technology Center Inc. Donald J. Roth, GE Aviation Ram P. Samy, NDE Information Consultants Steven M. Shepard, Thermal Wave Imaging Ripi Singh, Inspiring Next Surendra Singh, Honeywell Roderic K. Stanley, NDE Information Consultants Mike C. Tsao, University of Connecticut – Avery Point Lianxiang Yang, Oakland University Reza Zoughi, Iowa State University CONTRIBUTING EDITORS John Z. Chen, Schlumberger (Back to Basics) Bruce G. Crouse, Inspection Services Robert E. Shannon, Siemens Energy Inc. (New Patents) Materials Evaluation (ISSN 0025-5327) is published monthly by the American Society for Nondestructive Testing Inc. Periodical postage paid at Columbus, Ohio, and additional mailing offices. Posted under Canadian IPM #0312819. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Materials Evaluation, 1711 Arlingate Lane, PO Box 28518, Columbus, OH 43228-0518. Materials Evaluation is an archival journal in nondestructive testing/evaluation/inspection. The journal’s technical articles are refereed by experts in their fields and the papers are abstracted by major technical abstracting services, including: Acoustic Abstracts Alloys Index Aluminum Industry Abstracts Applied Mechanics Review Applied Science and Technology Index Cadscan Corrosion Abstracts Current Contents Energy Science & Technology Engineered Materials Abstracts Engineering Index Exploration and Production Health, Safety and Environment Gas Processing and Pipelining Highway Research Info Service INIS Atomindex INSPEC, Institution of Electrical Engineers ISMEC, Mechanical Engineering Abstracts Index to Scientific Reviews International Aerospace Abstracts Leadscan Metals Abstracts Metals Information Nondestructive Testing Information Analysis Center Nonferrous Metals Alert Offshore Technology PASCAL PIRA Petroleum Abstracts Polymers, Ceramics, Composites Alert Science Abstracts (Physics Abstracts, Electrical and Electronics Abstracts and Computer and Control Abstracts) Science Citation Index Solid State and Superconductivity Abstracts Steels Alert and Zincscan. Subscriptions to Materials Evaluation (noncommissionable) to other than members of the Society: $135 per year domestic $245 (prepaid) per year international, which includes special handling outside the USA. Single copy price: $9 for members ($12 for nonmembers). Claims for replacement of lost or damaged copies must be made in writing, received within 60 days of the date of publication. No more than two claims for replacement copies will be honored in a single year. Printed in the United States of America. Copyright © 2020 by the American Society for Nondestructive Testing Inc. The American Society for Nondestructive Testing Inc. (ASNT) is not responsible for the authenticity or accuracy of the information herein. Published opinions and statements do not necessarily reflect the opinions of ASNT. Products or services that are advertised or mentioned do not carry the endorsement or recommendation of ASNT. IRRSP, NDT Handbook, The NDT Technician, and asnt.org are trademarks of the American Society for Nondestructive Testing Inc. ACCP, ASNT, Level III Study Guide, Materials Evaluation, Nondestructive Testing Handbook, Research in Nondestructive Evaluation, and RNDE are registered trademarks of the American Society for Nondestructive Testing Inc. Authorization to photocopy fee-coded items for internal or personal use or the internal or personal use of specific clients, is granted by the American Society for Nondestructive Testing Inc., for libraries and other users registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC) Transactional Reporting Service, provided that the base fee of $2.50 per copy plus $1.00 per page is paid directly to CCC, 27 Congress St., Salem, MA 01970 website copyright.com. A fee code (0025-5327/97/$2.50/0) should be used in transactions with CCC and covers all material to be photocopied beyond that photocopying permitted by Section 107 or 108 of the US Copyright Law. This consent does not extend to other kinds of copying, such as copying for general distribution, for advertising or promotional purposes, for creating new collective works or for resale. The American Society for Nondestructive Testing asnt.org ASNT MISSION STATEMENT ASNT exists to create a safer world by advancing scientific, engineering, and technical knowledge in the field of nondestructive testing. SOCIETY OFFICERS CHAIRPERSON OF THE BOARD: Scott P. Cargill, Mistras Group Inc., 2020 PRESIDENT: Michael V. McGloin, NDT Enterprises, 2020 VICE PRESIDENT: John T. Iman, Acuren, 2020 SECRETARY/TREASURER: Danny L. Keck, KCS Enterprises, 2020 DIRECTORS AT LARGE Marwan Basrawi, DiTECHT Science & Technology Consultancy, 2022 John Z. Chen, Schlumberger, 2020 Tsuchin (Philip) Chu, Southern Illinois University, 2022 James (Gerry) Churchwell, Shawcor Inspection Services, 2022 John C. Duke, Jr., Virginia Tech University, 2020 Sebastian Z. Fernandes, Petrofac, 2021 John J. Kinsey, TRC Solutions, 2021 David H. Mitchell, Sr., Arcadia Aerospace Industries, 2021 C. Deal Moore, NDT Seals Inc., 2020 COUNCIL DIRECTORS CERTIFICATION MANAGEMENT COUNCIL: Martin T. Anderson, Alaska Technical Training, 2020 ENGINEERING COUNCIL: Ahmed Arabi Hassen, Oak Ridge National Library, 2021 RESEARCH COUNCIL: Anish Poudel, Transportation Technology Center Inc., 2022 SECTION OPERATIONS COUNCIL: William F. Via, Jr., Virginia Department of Transportation, 2020 TECHNICAL & EDUCATION COUNCIL: Lawrence W. Gill, General Dynamics Electric Boat, 2022